Is Having A Job Essential To Our Identity?
Let’s start with a sobering thought: for many of us, our job isn’t just what we do — it’s who we are. It’s the handshake we offer at parties, the title in our email signature, the answer to the small talk question we all dread: “So, what do you do?” Strip that away, and what’s left? A person? Or a shell?
Psychologist Carl Jung argued that the human psyche is composed of masks — personas we adopt to navigate the world. The job, for most of us, is the primary mask. It’s the one we wear the most, the one that shields us from the existential question of identity. Without it, we’re left naked, vulnerable, staring into the abyss of uncertainty.
I’ve been there. My career has defined me, anchored me, and sometimes even deceived me. I’ve worn the mask of success, convincing others — and myself — that my worth was tied to my LinkedIn profile. When you strip away the title, the accolades, the deadlines, you’re left with something raw and unnervingly human. It’s liberating in theory, terrifying in practice.
Work as Identity
Work isn’t just a means to pay the bills. It’s a way to matter. Think about it: the question “What do you do?” is shorthand for “Why should I care about you?” That’s harsh, but it’s true. Our society worships productivity. We’re told our value lies in the output we create, the revenue we generate, the problems we solve. It’s not just what we do; it’s who we are.
When you don’t have a job, you’re not just unemployed — you’re untethered. People stop asking what you do, and that question becomes internalized. You ask yourself: What am I worth if I’m not contributing? This isn’t just a personal crisis; it’s a societal failure. We’ve built a culture where identity is a transaction. You matter if you produce. Period.
But here’s the thing: when your identity is so tightly coupled with your profession, losing your job doesn’t just create a financial gap — it creates a chasm in your sense of self.
The Comfort of the Mask
Jung’s concept of masks isn’t inherently negative. Masks help us function. They allow us to show up, shake hands, smile through the awkwardness. The mask of the “professional” makes it easier to navigate a world that values structure over chaos. But the problem arises when the mask becomes glued to our face.
I’ve met CEOs who are terrified of retirement, not because they’ll miss the boardroom but because they’ll lose the mask. Without the title, who are they? A retired CEO isn’t a CEO; they’re just retired. The same is true for anyone who defines themselves by their work. Take away the mask, and you risk exposing the insecurity, the doubt, the fear that maybe — just maybe — you’re not enough without it.
The Void and the Opportunity
Here’s the paradox: losing the mask can also be the moment you find yourself. When you lose your job — or voluntarily step away from it — you’re forced to confront the void. It’s uncomfortable. It’s messy. But it’s also where growth happens.
Think of it this way: most of us are so busy climbing the ladder that we never stop to ask if it’s leaning against the right wall. A job loss can feel like falling off the ladder, but it’s also a chance to reassess, realign, and rebuild. Who are you when you’re not your job? What do you value? What drives you?
The answers to those questions don’t come easy. They take time, reflection, and, yes, a little bit of pain. But they’re worth it. Because on the other side of the void isn’t just another mask — it’s a deeper understanding of yourself.
Redefining Value
This isn’t a manifesto against work. I love work. It gives me purpose, focus, and structure. But I’ve also learned that tying my identity solely to my job is a dangerous game. Your value isn’t in your job title; it’s in your ability to adapt, to connect, to contribute in ways that go beyond your LinkedIn endorsements.
The world needs a shift in perspective. We need to decouple worth from work, identity from income. Imagine a society where we ask, “What do you care about?” instead of “What do you do?” It’s radical, but it’s necessary. Because when the chips are down — when the company folds, the layoff notice lands, or the retirement party ends — what’s left isn’t the job. It’s you.
A Call to Action
If you’ve lost your job, I won’t sugarcoat it: it sucks. The financial stress, the social awkwardness, the existential crisis — it’s brutal. But it’s also an opportunity. Use it. Reflect. Rebuild. Redefine what success looks like for you. Maybe it’s starting a business. Maybe it’s finally writing that book. Maybe it’s simply being present for your family.
And if you’re still in the grind, take a moment to think about the mask you’re wearing. Is it authentic? Does it align with who you are — or who you want to be? Because here’s the truth: one day, the mask will come off. Whether it’s by choice or circumstance, you’ll face the void. The question isn’t if — it’s when. And when that moment comes, I hope you find not just emptiness, but possibility.
In the end, a person without a job isn’t nothing. They’re a person — just like you. The mask may be gone, but the human remains. And that’s where the real work begins.
Hey there, if you like how I think, consider buying your copy of Talk Tech To Me. It’s the non-technical approach to tech recruiting that gives you competence and confidence as you take on the throws of technical recruiting the next generation of builders! Thank you!
