When Bad Hiring Practices Go Unchecked

Brian Fink
3 min readAug 17, 2024

--

Photo by Fulvio Ciccolo on Unsplash

In the modern corporate Colosseum, where combatants vie not with swords but with strategic maneuvers, one might presume that wisdom would prevail. Yet, here we are, doubling down on hiring practices that have as much success as a Diet Coke has calories — none. It’s akin to playing a broken slot machine, yet expecting a jackpot with each depressing pull.

The Illusion of More Is Better

In the world of hiring, quantity over quality often rules the roost. In a bewildering display of optimism, companies assume that casting a wider net will snag that elusive marlin-sized talent. Instead, they end up with a boatload of sardines. You see, when firms stubbornly stick to outdated hiring scripts and flooded job boards, they create a paradoxical world where more actually means less — less quality, less fit, and certainly, less sanity.

The Copy-Paste Catastrophe

The “best practices” in hiring often resemble a viral meme — everyone shares it, but few understand why. This copy-paste culture in recruitment strategies leads to a bland uniformity, where every job description reads like it was churned out by a deranged bot obsessed with “dynamic self-starters” and “ninja rockstars.”

The result?

A homogenized talent pool where differentiation is as rare as humility at a venture capital pitch.

The Myth of the Perfect Match

Every company desires the mythical ‘perfect fit’ — a creature so rare, it’s rumored to be on the endangered species list right next to honest politicians. In pursuit of this, firms often deploy an arsenal of assessments, personality tests, and what not, which can predict everything except, ironically, job performance. It’s a corporate version of a dating app where you swipe endlessly, hoping the next one will be The One.

The Feedback Void

Post-interview feedback often disappears into a black hole, much like my respect for people who wear socks with sandals. Companies fail to close the loop, leading candidates to wander in a limbo of uncertainty. This feedback famine not only starves candidates of improvement but also strips firms of the chance to refine their own failing systems.

Automation Ad Absurdum

In an ode to efficiency, firms lean heavily on automated systems — software that can somehow sift through thousands of resumes with the dispassionate efficiency of a Terminator. Yet, this reliance on algorithms to detect human potential is like using a metal detector to find a four-leaf clover. It’s not only ineffective, it’s borderline absurd.

The Cost of Complacency

The true cost of these archaic hiring practices is staggering — not just in monetary terms, but in missed opportunities, innovation stifled, and morale bulldozed. Companies that refuse to innovate their hiring strategies are like dinosaurs watching the meteor of change hurtle towards them, blissfully unaware of the impending impact.

A Call for Revolutionary Prudence

It’s high time companies stopped hitting the snooze button on their hiring alarm clocks. The need of the hour is not to double down on faulty practices, but to dismantle them completely. Innovate, iterate, and invigorate the hiring process with practices grounded in reality, not in wishful thinking. After all, the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again, but expecting different results — a lesson in futility that even corporate giants must learn.

Doubling down on hiring practices that don’t work is a fool’s errand, akin to expecting a diet solely of fast food to result in weight loss. It’s time for a strategic pivot, lest we continue to spin our wheels in the mud of mediocrity. Let’s not just think outside the box; let’s rethink the box entirely.

Hi there, I’m Brian, and in addition to this Medium, I’m writing the proverbial (no surprise here) sequel to Talk Tech To Me. I take on the stress and strain of complex technology concepts and simplify them for the modern recruiter.

--

--

Brian Fink
Brian Fink

Written by Brian Fink

Executive Recruiter. ✈ #ATL ↔ #SF ✈ Building companies is my favorite. Opinions are my own. Responsibility is freedom. 🖖

No responses yet